Admit Submit Commit Transmit
AskJamesOne_Cover_front
Ask hard questions.
Find satisfying answers.
Get Yours Today.



The WeatherPixie


RSS Feeds:
Add to My Yahoo
Add to AOL
Add to Google
My RYC Rule
I reply to every comment. I leave my reply under the same post where you left your comment. I almost never “RYC” back at your site. I normally post my replies just before putting up my next new post.

Candor, Intelligence, Good Will
All dialog of this sort is welcome here.
About this Entry
Posted by: FKIProfessor

Visit FKIProfessor's Xanga Site

Original: 7/8/2009 10:39 AM
Views: 39
Comments: 8
eProps: 10

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site

Who recommended?

Who gave the eProps?
2 eProps!2 eProps! 2 eProps from:
PreciousOnyx
QuantumStorm
LSP1
New1E13_15
tsh44

Wednesday, July 08, 2009

Creative Science 8 - Causality

 Do not be deceived, God is not mocked; for whatever a man sows, this he will also reap.” Gal 6:7 (NASB)

It takes very little faith to believe the old saying, “you reap what you sow.” It is common sense. Such a simple saying is taken for granted, yet it has profound consequences. The scientific method is based on cause and effect which in turn is based on this very basic and simple truth: you reap what you sow. If you plant a tomato seed, you get more tomatoes. The whole of science is based on the reliability of cause and effect in nature. Tomato seeds cause tomatoes. Nothing else can cause a tomato and a tomato seed can cause nothing else.

Around 400 AD a Christian named John Philoponus used the basic rule of cause and effect to argue against the Naturalism of his own day. His argument is known today as the Kalam Principle. Kalam literally means “speech” or “doctrine.” The Kalam Principle says that whatever begins to exist has a cause; the universe began to exist; so the universe has a cause.

For centuries it was generally believed the universe was steady state. In general the steady state theory says the universe is unchanging and may be infinite in size, content, and time. There are logical problems with this idea. In the real universe, you cannot add one to infinity because it is already infinite, thus you cannot add a new sun, moon, planet, galaxy, or even atoms. The universe mathematically and philosophically cannot have an infinite past, thus is must have had a beginning. In spite of this practical reality, Materialists supported steady state theory to avoid a beginning. Beginning was regarded as the faulty logic of the Kalam principle. If the universe is eternal there is no beginning, thus no cause, thus no logical need for a Creator.

Einstein’s theory of relativity was demonstrated to be true in the 1920s. Among other things, Einstein’s theory of relativity requires the universe to be expanding rather than steady state. If the universe is spreading out, it stands to reason it was once compact. If that is true, it stands to reason it must have begun expanding from some much smaller size than we observe today. These obvious conclusions form the basis for Big Bang theory – nearly gospel today among astronomers and laymen alike who prefer the philosophy of Evolution. These obvious conclusions also support the Creation model. The application of Einstein’s relativity is, therefore, relative.

Initially Big Bang theory was rejected by the Materialistic science community because it requires a definite beginning. Then something amazing happened. Materialists stopped arguing against a beginning. Instead, they now argue against the requirement for a cause. The very foundation of science itself is causality. It should be obvious that for something to begin to exist it must have a cause. To avoid the requisite “why,” Materialist scientists propose the universe came from nothing by a natural chance mechanism. For lack of a better natural explanation, they suggest such unlikely causes as quantum uncertainties. In any realm of science (other than Materialist cosmology) the idea of uncaused beginning would be absurd. When confronted with the fallacy of their argument, they generally respond with the obvious question: “If the universe has a beginning and a prime cause, and if that cause is God, then who or what created God?” This very question has been raised countless times in opposition to God. The Materialist hopes to create a loop of circular logic demonstrating the flaw in belief in God and confounding the Creationist. The answer is simple and elegant. God is eternal. Since God has no beginning, God requires no cause. God is the prime cause of material reality – time, space, energy, and matter.

Once you reach the logical conclusion the universe was caused, then the philosophical question of why cannot be avoided. Evolution does not presume to suppose an answer to the question of why. Big Bang and Evolution theories are human contrivances. No human observed the beginning of life, let alone the universe, therefore no human can know with certainty how it began. The biblical account of Creation is the divinely revealed answer. Genesis offers not only a brief overview of what God did, but much more importantly it offers us answers to the nagging question why.

Cause may be personal or impersonal. For example, if a wife makes a pot of coffee for her husband, you could explain the cause of the coffee personally or impersonally. The impersonal explanation is that the hot water passes over the grounds to produce the drink. The personal explanation is that the wife loves her husband and made the coffee to please him. When we try to answer the question of the why the universe exists with an impersonal description of how, we fail to answer the real question – why. When we ask why the universe exists, we are really asking why we personally exist. We seek to know the meaning of life. Apart from God’s revelation of Himself and His purposes we cannot possibly exceed human philosophy and impersonal guesswork.

Gen 1:22 is the first of several occasions in scripture where God commands his creatures to be fruitful and multiply. Life is commanded to procreate according to its own created kind (Gen 1:24). God says this is good (Gen 1:25). Humans are unique among creation because we are created in God’s image (Gen 1:27). Humans are given responsibility to manage and care for the rest of creation (Gen 1:28). God endowed mankind with similarity to Himself, the ability to have children, authority over nature, and responsibility to love and care for creation as God loves and cares for us. Gen 2:15 gives a more specific job description – to cultivate and care for the garden. Gen 2:16 shows us that God endowed us with free will and the opportunity to use it to obey Him and remain holy or disobey him and know the sting of sin and death. Prior to the introduction of sin, there was no shame or guilt (Gen 2:25). God established marriage as the foundation of the family and the ideal environment for raising children (Gen 2:24). In all these acts of God we see His divine love revealed as the answer to why we exist and why we do the most basic things we do.
 Posted 7/8/2009 10:39 AM - 39 Views - 10 eProps - 8 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

8 Comments

Visit PreciousOnyx's Xanga Site!
I first learned about Kalam in Strobel's the Case for a Creator. awesome stuff:)
Posted 7/8/2009 11:11 AM by PreciousOnyx - reply

Visit QuantumStorm's Xanga Site!
//
Einstein’s theory of relativity was demonstrated to be true in the 1920s.//

It wasn't demonstrated to be "True". Rather, it gained a considerable amount of empirical support in the 20s. Subtle difference, I know.

//To avoid the requisite “why,” Materialist scientists propose the universe came from nothing by a natural chance mechanism. //

Why can't God use natural mechanisms to enact His Will?
Posted 7/8/2009 11:14 AM by QuantumStorm - reply

Visit LSP1's Xanga Site!
[“If the universe has a beginning and a prime cause, and if that cause is God, then who or what created God?”]

If there's no beginning to time, we could not arrive at the present. Something had to eternally exist outside of the universe and time, which caused the universe and time to exist.
Posted 7/8/2009 2:35 PM by LSP1 - reply

Visit FKIProfessor's Xanga Site!

@PreciousOnyx - Actually this chapter is adapted from notes I took while reading through that very book.


@QuantumStorm - Regarding Einstein's theory being demonstrated rather than true, point taken. In answer to your question "Why can't God use natural mechanisms to enact His Will?": The question is itself something of an oxymoron, don't you think? Okay, seriously... I believe God put nature into motion and intervenes only when He wishes to impose His will. However, the universe did not come about by natural means. That's the whole point. Nature cannot produce nature from nothing. Simple logic implies and imho requires the existence of divine supernatural mind. If you referring to evolution, I'm not convinced "macro" evolution is even remotely a valid proposition. If you weren't referring to evolution, then please disregard this comment as I have plenty of fodder for your scrutiny in upcoming posts.

Posted 7/10/2009 7:47 PM by FKIProfessor Xanga True Member - reply

Visit QuantumStorm's Xanga Site!

@FKIProfessor - 



//However, the universe did not come about by natural means. //

Well, if God can use natural means, then it follows that the universe COULD have come about by natural means and thus, by extension, God's Hand.
Posted 7/10/2009 10:55 PM by QuantumStorm - reply

QuantumStorm said "if God can use natural means, then it follows that the universe COULD have come about by natural means and thus, by extension, God's Hand."



While I see reason in this argument, reason has also already been given in a previous chapter as to why ID/theistic evolution is not really being discussed further. Maybe it needed to be made more clear in that chapter that it wouldn't be taken beyond that.
Posted 7/11/2009 12:45 PM by snowberry - reply

Visit New1E13_15's Xanga Site!
Nice this is a great post. While I agree God most often uses the natural order of things I believe when he acts directly he tends to contradict it so that his handiwork is more apparent to those who will see.
Posted 7/11/2009 4:28 PM by New1E13_15 Xanga Lifetime Member - reply

Visit tsh44's Xanga Site!
Thank you for referring me to this post. I'm happy that I came to read it.
Posted 10/22/2009 8:59 PM by tsh44 Xanga Lifetime Member - reply


Choose Identity
(?)
 
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
  • Say it with Minis! (?)

Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to FKIProfessor's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in FKIProfessor's local time zone:
GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)
Creation Posts
Creative Science I-13
Philosophy
Cosmology
Solar System
Earth Sciences
Physics
Life
Anthro/Paleo
Summary
Creation v Evolution I
Creation v Evolution II
Spiritual Brain
Biblical Astronomy
Nuclear Physics
E=mc2

Faith Matters
Abortion
Anger
Angering God
Armory
Baptism & Forgiveness
Bible Timeline
Blaspheme
Born Again: What?
Born Again: How?
The Consistency of God
Wrong Crucifixion Date
Right Crucifixion Date
Donuts
Does God Deceive?
Facing Temptation
Facing Satan
Faith v. Works
Feasts of Israel
From Desire to Sin
From Satan to Death
From God to Life
Hearing God
Homosexuality a Sin?
Hope
Justice v. Forgiveness
Kinds of Law
Perfect Law
Liberty
Law of Liberty
10 Commandments
Maturity v. Independence
Meekness
Peter v. Judas
Taking Life is Human?
Rapture
Repent - Part 1
Repent - Part 2
Salvation Conditions
Who is Satan?
Surviving Trials
Why Testing?
Testing Tests
What Doers Do
Why God Says No

Personal Faith
Salvation Statement
Do you have a ticket?
Deal With It
How To Deal With It
Suicide - Part 1
Suicide - Part 2
7-Ups
George Street Tracts
Donuts for Push-ups

Best of Personal Logs
Who Is FKI Professor?
Why I Xanga
Weeping for Pompeii
The Road to the Cavern
Confessions of a sinner
Introspective Weekend
Judge Lance
Interviewing Angels
The Tree
One Word Quiz
I Dare You
The Quiz Answers
Poison Ivy
Dog Lessons
Interviewing Angels
The Pastor from Hell
Letter to Pastor
My Neighborhood in Pictures
My Native Land (Indiana)
You're from Indiana if...
Salem Castle
Kentucky Pics 1
Kentucky Pics 2
Kentucky Pics 3
Yard Tour
Country Road Observations
Shoes & Trees
Lance Vs. Septic
Weight Goal Reached
Happy Anniversary
Bulldozer in Camelot
Invertaphobia
Man's Best Friend
Summer Camp 2006
Copperhead Story
The Show Must Go On
Fair Parade

Bible Studies
The 12 - Overview
Hosea
Joel
Amos
Obadiah
Jonah
Micah
Nahum
Habakkuk
Zephaniah
Jer 8:4-7
1 Cor 15
Phil 2:8-13
PDL Index
James Index

Challenge Chapters
Challenge Intro
Challenge Explained
Genesis 2
Genesis 3
Genesis 7
Genesis 11
Genesis 27
Genesis 32
Leviticus 8
Lev 23: Intro
Lev 23: Sabbath
Lev 23: Passover
Lev 23: Unleavened Bread
Lev 23: Weeks
Lev 23: Trumpets
Lev 23: Atonement
Lev 23: Tabernacles
Numbers 1
Joshua 2
Joshua 9
Joshua 13
Joshua 16
Judges 2
Judges 20
1 Samuel 3
2 Kings 3
Job 8
Psalm 44
Psalm 94
Psalm 144
Proverbs 8
Proverbs 20
Eccl 7
Isaiah 51
Isaiah 66
Jer 12
Jer 36
Lam 5
Hosea 14
Jonah 4
Nahum 3
John 3
Luke 14
1 Cor 15
Hebrews 1
Revelation 4
Revelation 22

Battlestar Galactica
Galactica Station
Galactica Primer
All Along the Watchtower
Galactica’s Hope
Galactica Allegorical
Popularity of Galactica
Galactica vs. Trek
Gaius Baltar
Cylon Santa
R.I.P. Kara Thrace
Baltar’s Trial
Why I'm a BSG Fan
BSG Gadgets
Cylons In America

Entertainment
Hayswood Theatre
Horton Hears a Who
Emily Rose
The Wall
Star Trek Experience
Abbott & Costello
Wallace and Grommit
Dead Bodies
Davey Crocket Book Review
Autumn
My Music Library
Sudoku
Toast
Badger
Bubble Wrap

History & Politics
Fair Tax
Liberty Vs. Security
No to Ron Paul
Jane Goodall
Christmas
Lincoln Thanksgiving
Armed Forces Day
Memorial Day Tribute
Dec 7 1941
Nuclear Accidents
Man on the Moon
History
Time
Justifiable Conflicts
Social Security
Yasir Arafat
Iraqi Constitution

Bible Resources
ESV Bible Online
Interlinear Bible
Greek New Testament
Bible Gateway

News Resources
Town Hall
Coldhearted Truth
Real Clear Politics
Hugh Hewitt
Drudge
White House
Fox News
Jerusalem Post
Moscow Times
Hoax Busters
Good News from Iraq
Today in History
Astronomy Pics
Biblical Astronomy
Hurricane Map
Earthquake Map
Corydon Dark Sky Map

Fellow Xangans
Bee’s Super Sidebar
Anna’s Super Sidebar
NT on 6-Days
Evolution Argument
Trotsky v God
Colors
On Modern Evangelism
Human Eye
Reincarnation
Starlight
Earth Age Rate
The DNA Problem
Big 10 Visual
Why Punishment?
Nephilim
Meekness
Is God Logical?
X-Rated Sermon
Law in Evangelism
Seeking Our Roots
English Channel
Beatitudes
Toasting Tina
Tina’s Guest Post
Larry’s Guest Post
Steve’s Guest Post
Pheebles’ Guest Post
Shell’s Guest Post
Faith Cycle Ministries Faith Cycle Ministries Faith Cycle Ministries

”Where


Quotable Quotes
"The Greeks study to comprehend; the Hebrews study to revere." - Abraham Joshua Heschel
"Every saint has a past, every sinner has a future." - Dr. William Bennett
"Hurt doesn't have to be healed quickly to be healed eternally." — Lance Ponder
"You got something to live for now. Not just die for." — Karl Agathon
"Uniformity of faith does not equal uniformity of thought." — me
"Love enhances obedience; it does not displace it." — Leigh Ann
"No matter how much tinting I use, the walls of my house are still glass." — me
"Buddha said, 'My teachings point the way to the attainment of the truth.' Muhammad said, 'The truth has been revealed to me.' Jesus said, 'I am the truth.'" - Tina
"How do you make holy water? You boil the hell out of it." - Brad
"My level of stupidity does not change God's level of grace" - Michael Garrett
"How could God create something from nothing, yet I can create only nothing from something!" - Poet Rose
"God answers everyone's prayers." - Leoben, a Cylon
“The vast mysteries of the universe should only confirm our belief in the certainty of its Creator. I find it as difficult to understand a scientist who does not acknowledge the presence of a superior rationality behind the existence of the universe as it is to comprehend a theologian who would deny the advances of science.” – Werner von Braun.